Browse the WBW Podcast
Browse the WBW Podcast
Browse Classic Who reviews
Browse Classic Who reviews

The Doctor & Co go on a road trip to Peking with Marco Polo. Meanwhile, a man by the name of Tegana is plotting to steal the TARDIS.

The Doctor, Susan, Barbara and Ian arrive on the Plain of Pamir, see a yeti twice and never mention it ever again. Then they’re held captive, as per usual, by a group of Mongols and a European dude named Marco Polo. One of the former, Tegana, believes they’re mountain spirits; Marco Polo thinks they’re too valuable to kill; and both of them want to steal the TARDIS. And so off they go on a road trip to see the Kublai Khan.

This is the first of many lost Doctor Who stories – lost in the sense, that we can only really listen to the episodes, not watch them. However, a fantastic and nerdy production company called ‘Loose Cannon Productions’ re-assembled this Doctor Who story from the original audio, still photos taken on set during production and a video (re)creation of the intro and outro, featuring Mark Eden who played the titular character back in 1963.

(Our Ratings and Reviews of this Doctor Who story kick in at the 1h25m45s mark.)

Here's what we think of C004 Marco Polo

We rate Doctor Who stories on a scale from 0.0 to 5.0. For context, very few are excellent enough to merit a 5.0 in our minds, and we'd take a 0.0 Doctor Who story over a lot of other, non-Whovian stuff out there.

Leon | @ponken


Flapjack | @12Manymornings


Here's what we think of C004 Marco Polo

We rate Doctor Who stories on a scale from 0.0 to 5.0. For context, very few are excellent enough to merit a 5.0 in our minds, and we'd take a 0.0 Doctor Who story over a lot of other, non-Whovian stuff out there.

Leon | @ponken


Flapjack | @12Manymornings


Here's what you think 4 Responses to “C004 Marco Polo”
  1. They talk about a yeti at the beginning and they THINK they see one. In reality it was one of the caravan dressed up in snowshoes (snow shoe) and lots of furs. He gets scared off and goes to tell the rest when the screams happen. It’s explained in the text in the reproduction. That’s why the caravan finds them. Raise that rating higher!

    I absolutely love this story. Loose Canon (a few fans (three primarily) who did this all on their own) did an amazing job at not only re-creating the story, but in colorizing the images. They actor did the intro and outro out of love for the story. There was no budget as it was not a real company. No money was ever made, but you guys probably know all this by now.

    So sad it’s not still available. The Dr and Kahn are such a great pair.

    Thanks for all your effort guys!

  2. ‘Marco Polo’ sees the Doctor and the TARDIS crew thrown back into history: into 1289 to be precise. The TARDIS breaks down in the middle of the Himalayas and the group are captured/rescued by a caravan led by civilised explorer Marco Polo and scheming warlord Tigana.

    Marco claims the TARDIS for the great Kublai Khan, hoping to use it to gain his freedom. If they are ever to win it back, our intrepid travellers must accompany them on their road-trip through medieval China to the imperial city of Peking. Thus begins an epic tale that is tragically missing in its entirety, and now only available as a reconstruction.

    First up, this works brilliantly as a human story. The characters are excellent, especially Marco Polo, Tigana and Kublai Khan. Each is a fully rounded character and thus totally believable. Even the walk on parts, such as Wang-lo (the fussy hotelier) or Kuiju (him with the eye-patch and the monkey!) are more than just plot devices and are genuinely entertaining.

    Also, the sheer length and breadth of this story sets it apart from a typical Dr Who adventure. The TARDIS crew spend more than a month travelling over 4000km from the plain of Pamir in modern Tajikstan across to Beijing (Peking) by the Pacific Ocean. As the Muppets pointed out, the fastest way to travel is by map, and the caravan does exactly that. These animated sections, with Marco Polo’s journal as a voiceover, are brilliant transitions between the various set pieces.

    The design of the show is breathtakingly beautiful – the costumes, props and sets are magnificent, making it all the more frustrating that the footage is missing and we are only left with stills.

    There are a few logical gaps, which could do with a bit of explanation. Why do Ian and Barbara wander about on the Himalayas looking for fuel, when there is a TARDIS full of junk that they can set on fire? (One of the Doctors old armchairs, perhaps?) Why do they all nearly die of dehydration when there is a well set up ‘water machine’ inside the TARDIS? (I’m assuming it’s after his experiences here that the Doctor decided to install the TARDIS swimming pool?) Why does Marco Polo not look inside the TARDIS? Why doesn’t Tigana kill everyone a thousand times over on the journey? Why does he wait till he is surrounded by the Khan’s guards before revealing his treachery?
    The greatest misery is simply that the show is missing. It’s one of the biggest holes in the Who collection.

    The CGI version I was watching included a sequence in episode 2 where, after Ian and Barbara realise Susan and Ping-Cho are missing in a sand story, they then stand awkwardly in the tent, looking around at the ceiling and the floor shouting “Susan! Susan!”
    At the end of episode four, Ian cuts his way out of the tent with a fruit knife. He approaches a guard, about to (presumably) stab him in the eyeball, when he discovers he is already dead. Great episode ending!
    Hearing the TARDIS has been stored in the stables, the Doctor furiously imitates the hotelier’s voice. “ ‘I couldn’t leave it in the Hanging Gardens, could I?’ – What does he think it is, a potting shed?” Great line, Doctor!
    During the backgammon game, Kublai Khan asks the Doctor what he currently owes him. The Doctor replies smugly “Thirty-five elephants with ceremonial bridles, trappings, brocades and pavilions; four thousand white stallions; twenty five tigers and the sacred tooth of Buddha.” (I imagine the Doctor like some sort of futuristic Noah herding these thirty five ceremonial elephants into his TARDIS. And what exactly he plans on doing with Buddha’s tooth is anybody’s guess!)

    Inevitably there are concerns about racism in a 60s BBC story set in Asia. It’s certainly a shame that all the characters are played by white people, and the story would undoubtedly be stronger if Chinese or Mongol actors had played their respective roles. Similarly, the fact that Marco is a white goodie and Tigana is an Asian baddie is not ideal representation. However, Kublai Khan is an Asian goodie, and Tigana is not just a thug – he is a complex human character, and all in all, viewed as a piece of it’s time, I feel it unnecessary to get on a high horse about this serial.

    There’s an innocence about this story that works brilliantly in the context of first season Dr Who. There’s no aliens (if we discount the disputable appearance of a yeti in episode one – I’m not convinced!), there’s no masterplans, there’s no grand villainy – there’s only ordinary people caught up in history and making choices, good or bad. It’s a lovely human drama, and while the plot meanders along, that fits its ‘road trip’ genre perfectly.

    Overall: 3.9*
    [NB: I don’t make allowances for it being missing here. I am grading the recon I saw. So giving this 3.9 means I would rather watch the recon of Marco Polo than the surviving footage of any of the previous stories.]

  3. Peter Zunitch

    I never submitted a proper review for this. Here it is:

    Like many of us, I’ve never seen a single second of movement from this story. If I did, would my rating go down? It’s strange to think that I might be rating this higher just because the Loose Canon reconstruction is so good. It is by far the best telesnap recon. Sometimes when the full visual is seen, there are moments of bland sets and locations that take you out of the moment. Here, the colorized images along with very good quality audio really make me hang on to every moment, studying each shot intensely.
    There’s little need to talk about the writing, acting, music and sets because they’re all brilliant, and I hesitate to discuss the directing because we can’t fully experience it. Most serials of this length get berated for padding, but that’s not a problem here. The crew could have gone on several more adventures with Marco Polo and I would have been overjoyed. The dynamics between all of the characters is what drives this story home. Everyone is multidimensional, believable, and it only gets better when we finally meet Kublai Kahn.
    This is definitely the top missing story I would want recovered. What I wouldn’t give for 90 minutes of video? Still the audio and recon are so good you can close your eyes and re-create every moment yourself. How can the original production ever live up to one’s imagination? Still the only reason for any sort of deduction is because of what we’ve lost. 4.9

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

If you haven't already... Subscribe now!

Subscribe to us on iTunes now! We're dropping a new episode every week (pretty much), reviewing Classic Who, New Who and all kinds of bonus stuff from spin-offs and conventions to Doctor Who comic books.

We last reviewed...

N183 73 Yards